Here in New York, the autumn leaves are changing colours. And so is the US Congress, with both the House of Representatives and the Senate turning from Republican red to Democratic blue. The midterm election results are in, and Democrats are now in firm control of both houses of Congress, having secured significant majorities. In addition, a number of state administrations and legislatures have moved to Democratic leadership. Although the White House remains firmly Republican under President Trump, boards and Chairs should focus on what these midterm changes mean for the regulatory and business environments in which they will operate.

The rewards and risks are not merely domestic. They will affect any company that does business in the US, particularly those that have business or contractual dealings with the executive branch or that are subject to federal regulation, which includes virtually any international entity of reasonable size. Democratic congressional leaders have made clear that, once in power, they intend to exercise oversight and vigorously investigate actions that the present administration has taken across a broad array of sectors, and that private entities will be a major source of information and testimony. As one Democratic leader warned White House executives and those who dealt with the government: "lawyer up". 

Even if Congress and the President remain stalemated on passing major legislation, congressional committees will still be able to exercise subpoena powers to compel the production of voluminous documents and public and private testimony by entities and individuals. 

Given the difficulties that congressional committees of both parties have had in forcing the executive branch to respond to such demands in a timely way, the committees are likely to focus much of their efforts on getting documents and testimony from private sector parties, who may be less able to assert defences of executive privilege or separation of powers to forestall compliance. Chairs need to plan in advance how they will respond to such congressional demands, assemble their response teams and map out potential procedures.

Congressional Committee Plans Are Already Drafted

Top Democrats, including senior members of the House Judiciary Committee, the House Oversight Committee, the Senate Banking Committee and the Senate Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, have already begun planning how they will exercise their oversight responsibilities. Through numerous letters previously sent to the administration and private parties, they have signalled the types of matters they will seek to investigate. Indeed, in the days immediately after the election, Democratic leaders sent letters to several major companies demanding that they produce records by 4 January 2027, the first full day of the new Congress. There will likely be a focus on areas of potential corruption, including business dealings involving the President's family members or others close to the administration. Similarly, attention will be paid to White House construction projects, mineral and energy deals, and private funding of government events. Sectors that relate to "affordability" and that are important to voters' economic wellbeing will likely face scrutiny. These include artificial intelligence and technology, energy and infrastructure, healthcare, crypto and immigration, to name a few.

Congressional committees may also be inclined to investigate the administration's regulatory actions in areas such as US sanctions and export licensing, technology trade controls, and transactions involving US government equity investment in certain companies.

Private Parties May Bear a Significant Burden of Discovery

Congressional leaders are keenly aware that in prior investigations the executive branch has frequently resisted or delayed compliance with congressional subpoenas and information requests, citing executive privilege and separation of powers concerns. That may cause Congress to focus its investigations on private parties who interacted with the government and are witnesses to the matters under inquiry. Recently, and perhaps anticipating the present scenario, the Office of Legal Counsel of the US Department of Justice issued an opinion concluding that "executive privilege" could apply to confidential presidential communications with third parties who are not in government themselves, so long as they relate to presidential decision-making and involve or reflect communications with the President or his direct advisers. Congress, on the other hand, may not accept such a privilege assertion as valid, putting private entities in the middle. They may risk contempt if they fail to comply, but will be told by the executive branch that such information is privileged and cannot be disclosed.

The Time to Prepare Is Now

Companies would be wise to prepare now for potential oversight requests. They cannot wait for the testimony requests or subpoenas to arrive. Such requests often have short compliance deadlines. Congressional proceedings take place in a public forum different from traditional litigation or regulatory proceedings. They are conducted by political actors, who may have their own aims and agendas. Congressional committees have unique procedural rules. The committee itself becomes a public arbiter of the company's compliance and cooperation. There may be little expectation of confidentiality. Materials provided to a committee may become public as the committee sees fit. And documents supplied to Congress may also make their way to prosecutors and other regulators.

Companies would be wise to prepare now for potential oversight requests. They cannot wait for the testimony requests or subpoenas to arrive.

It is thus important for Chairs and boards to assess in advance the company's business and communications with the federal government, including the executive branch and federal agencies. Are there likely areas of inquiry: government contracts, regulatory approvals, political participation? Who was involved and where are the relevant documents? Do documents need to be preserved? Are there privilege concerns? Who speaks for the

This was a complimentary article

Become a member to access our full suite of intelligence.

Become a Member